America - The Jesuit Review
America - The Jesuit Review
  • 826
  • 11 979 879
An Israeli Jesuit on pro-Palestinian protests, antisemitism and demonizing narratives
As the war in the Holy Land continues to escalate and protests break out on university campuses around the world, Pope Francis persists in his calls for peace. But is it possible? Where does peace begin?
Released on May 9th, 2024, this episode of the “Inside the Vatican” podcast features David Neuhaus, S.J., an Israeli priest who teaches Scripture in Israel and Palestine, and works for peace in the Holy Land. He reflects on how Israeli Jews and Palestinian Arabs can engage in dialogue without dismissing each other’s painful histories, and emphasizes the need for nuanced and sensitive language in the current discourse about the war.
Topics:
00:00 - Context of the war and protests
2:10 - Student protests and polarizing narratives
5:40 - Antisemitism and Islamophobia
11:05 - The rise of demonizing narratives
12:20 - Understanding historical traumas
17:40 - Manipulated language vs. nuanced discourse
19:55 - Signs of hope for peace
24:26 - Political policies and interests
26:42 - The role of Catholic institutions in peacebuilding
29:49 - How Pope Francis is advocating for peace
Links:
- Patriarch Sabbah: The real cause of the war in Gaza-and the only path to peace: www.americamagazine.org/politics-society/2024/04/18/patriarch-sabbah-palestine-gaza-israel-247756
- There is a right and wrong way for Catholics to criticize Israel: www.americamagazine.org/politics-society/2024/01/18/israel-gaza-war-neuhaus-246974
- An Israeli Jesuit priest on the war in Gaza, Jewish-Catholic relations and the future of the two-state solution: www.americamagazine.org/politics-society/2024/01/05/israel-gaza-war-jesuit-neuhaus-246822
- ‘We can live together’: A Palestinian doctor and political activist on Gaza, a ceasefire and the future of Israel-Palestine: www.americamagazine.org/politics-society/2024/02/26/mustafa-barghouti-war-gaza-247379
---
America Media is the leading provider of editorial content for thinking Catholics and those who want to know what Catholics are thinking. To become a subscriber, visit www.americamagazine.org/subsc...
******
Sign-up for our newsletter: bit.ly/2Ka4SOi
******
Follow us on Social Media:
• America Media on Facebook: bit.ly/2Kal3Ll
• America Media on Twitter: bit.ly/2viJosZ
• America Media on Instagram: bit.ly/2Ka5q6O
******
Support more videos like this: bit.ly/2vgqm6A
Переглядів: 4 088

Відео

What young adults most need to hear in a homily | Preach
Переглядів 788Місяць тому
While most parishes struggle to attract young members, Saint Clement Parish in Chicago stands out with a mostly young adult congregation. This week on “Preach,” the Rev. Peter Wojcik, the pastor of Saint Clement Parish in Chicago, Ill., preaches for the Sixth Sunday of Easter, Year B. In his homily, he reflects on the depth of Jesus’ committed love for us and our Christian duty-and challenge-to...
What the Vatican said about gender in ‘Dignitas Infinita’
Переглядів 1,3 тис.Місяць тому
The Vatican released a document on human dignity in April 2024 with sections denouncing what it calls “gender theory” and “sex change.” In this special round table episode of the “Inside the Vatican” podcast, America’s Editor-in-Chief Fr. Sam Sawyer, S.J. and the Executive Director of Outreach, America’s LGBT Catholic resource, Michael O’Loughlin, join host Colleen Dulle for a discussion on the...
James Foley: A life of mercy and moral courage
Переглядів 5302 місяці тому
On Aug. 19, 2014, the world watched in horror as the American journalist James Foley read a script prepared for him by ISIS terrorists, who filmed him from an unknown location in the Syrian desert. Mr. Foley, who had been in ISIS captivity for almost two years, was then beheaded by his captors. That is how Diane Foley learned that her son, who had been kidnapped in Libya on a previous reporting...
Did Pope Francis punish Cardinal Burke?
Переглядів 9 тис.6 місяців тому
0:00 - Intro 01:00 - Pope Francis canceled his trip to the United Nations’ COP28 climate conference due to his ongoing bout of bronchitis. 10:40 - The pope's health and his message to the world on climate change. 18:51 - Pope Francis' decision to cut Cardinal Raymond Burke's salary from the Vatican’s payroll and possibly evict him from his Vatican apartment. 26:08 - Finally, the escalating conf...
Should the Synod on Synodality vote?
Переглядів 4 тис.8 місяців тому
For the first time in modern history, lay men and women have both been included as full, voting members of October's Synod on Synodality. But, argues the Rev. Louis Cameli, if this synod is not to be a “parliament,” as Pope Francis often warns, perhaps there should be no voting in the synod at all. Father Cameli, who is Cardinal Blase Cupich’s Delegate for Formation and Mission and a priest of ...
Pope Francis in Mongolia: China was the elephant in the room
Переглядів 1,9 тис.9 місяців тому
Vatican correspondent Gerry O'Connell traveled to Mongolia with Pope Francis from Aug. 31 to Sept. 4. On this episode of the “Inside the Vatican” podcast from America Media, Gerry and Colleen analyze the pope’s trip to one of the world’s most sparsely-populated countries, including the presence of a few Chinese pilgrims who risked punishment by their government to meet Pope Francis. Click here ...
Fr. James Martin on Jesus' greatest miracle | Jesuitical Podcast
Переглядів 4 тис.9 місяців тому
Jesuitical hosts Zac Davis and Ashley McKinless talk with their friend and colleague James Martin, S.J., who is out with a brand new book, Come Forth: The Promise of Jesus's Greatest Miracle. They discuss: 0:00 - Introduction 04:45 - Fr. Martin's relationship to the characters in the story of Lazarus 06:44 - The Gospels' telling of resurrection stories 10:16 - Fr. Martin's balance between schol...
Fr. James Martin's new book on Lazarus | Book Trailer
Переглядів 2,8 тис.9 місяців тому
"Come Forth: The Promise of Jesus's Greatest Miracle" is AVAILABLE NOW from HarperOne: link.chtbl.com/comeforth Father James Martin, SJ, one of America’s most beloved spiritual leaders and the New York Times bestselling author of The Jesuit Guide to (Almost) Everything and Learning to Pray, examines one of the most intriguing events in the New Testament-the story of Jesus raising Lazarus from t...
Why every Catholic church altar has a relic inside it
Переглядів 10 тис.11 місяців тому
Relics are parts of the body or material fragments associated with martyrs and saints, whom Catholics venerate. So why are they embedded in the altars of every Catholic church? In this video, you'll learn how relics are classified, how churches acquire relics and what happens to relics in shuttered or abandoned churches that no longer have a home? To support videos like this, become a digital s...
Cardinal Czerny on Pope Francis and the disputed legacy of Vatican II (FULL INTERVIEW)
Переглядів 3,3 тис.11 місяців тому
On the “Jesuitical” podcast, Zac David and producer Sebastian Gomes talk with Cardinal Michael Czerny, S.J., who leads the Vatican’s department for social justice and human development. Cardinal Czerny is also the co-author of the new book "Siblings All, Sign of the Times: The Social Teaching of Pope Francis". Topics include: 0:00 - Being a bishop for one day 2:25 - What it's like to work close...
How one bishop’s experience of suicide loss led him to start a mental health ministry
Переглядів 1,7 тис.Рік тому
On the Jesuitical podcast, Ashley McKinless and Zac Davis are joined by Bishop John Dolan of the Diocese of Phoenix to talk about losing several members of his family to suicide, a groundbreaking new mental health ministry in his diocese and how the church can better support those struggling with mental health issues. Read Bishop Dolan's feature article in America Magazine here: 'How losing fam...
A New Serenity Prayer | James Martin, S.J. and Terre Roche
Переглядів 22 тис.Рік тому
Fr. James Martin, SJ teams up with Terre Roche of "The Roches" for a musical rendition of "A New Serenity Prayer." The text of the prayer was written by Father Martin and set to music by Ms. Roche. At the end of the video, Father Martin and Ms. Roche chat about the project and what inspired their collaboration. You can find a full text of the prayer here: www.americamagazine.org/faith/2023/04/0...
Top 10 moments of Pope Francis
Переглядів 18 тис.Рік тому
In just 10 years, Pope Francis has had a world-changing papacy. From viral moments to global travel to groundbreaking papal documents, the pope has made a profound impact on the Catholic Church and the world. To commemorate Francis’ 10th anniversary America’s editors have chosen what we think are the top 10 most memorable moments of Francis’ papacy-so far. 0:00 - Pope Francis in 10 minutes 0:20...
FULL INTERVIEW: Cardinal McElroy on sex, sin, LGBT people, women and inclusion
Переглядів 24 тис.Рік тому
FULL INTERVIEW: Cardinal McElroy on sex, sin, LGBT people, women and inclusion
Why Pope Francis is visiting South Sudan
Переглядів 69 тис.Рік тому
Why Pope Francis is visiting South Sudan
Pope Francis is on a mission of peace in the Democratic Republic of Congo
Переглядів 3,9 тис.Рік тому
Pope Francis is on a mission of peace in the Democratic Republic of Congo
Was Pope Francis wrong to only mention Benedict XVI once in his funeral homily?
Переглядів 45 тис.Рік тому
Was Pope Francis wrong to only mention Benedict XVI once in his funeral homily?
Did Pope Benedict XVI further unite or divide the Christian churches?
Переглядів 8 тис.Рік тому
Did Pope Benedict XVI further unite or divide the Christian churches?
The unintended consequences of Pope Benedict XVI's resignation
Переглядів 6 тис.Рік тому
The unintended consequences of Pope Benedict XVI's resignation
Did Pope Benedict XVI suppress debate in the Catholic Church?
Переглядів 9 тис.Рік тому
Did Pope Benedict XVI suppress debate in the Catholic Church?
How Pope Benedict XVI shaped the modern Catholic Church | An Interview with George Weigel
Переглядів 17 тис.Рік тому
How Pope Benedict XVI shaped the modern Catholic Church | An Interview with George Weigel
Pope Benedict XVI: A Tribute
Переглядів 13 тис.Рік тому
Pope Benedict XVI: A Tribute
Do I have to follow every church teaching? | Think Like a Jesuit, Episode 5
Переглядів 25 тис.Рік тому
Do I have to follow every church teaching? | Think Like a Jesuit, Episode 5
Why Catholics should be involved in politics | Think Like a Jesuit, Episode 4
Переглядів 7 тис.Рік тому
Why Catholics should be involved in politics | Think Like a Jesuit, Episode 4
Are Critical Race Theory and Catholicism compatible? | Think Like a Jesuit, Episode 3
Переглядів 16 тис.Рік тому
Are Critical Race Theory and Catholicism compatible? | Think Like a Jesuit, Episode 3
Pope Francis gives an exclusive interview to America Media at the Vatican
Переглядів 10 тис.Рік тому
Pope Francis gives an exclusive interview to America Media at the Vatican
Who should be allowed to receive Communion? | Think Like a Jesuit, Episode 2
Переглядів 15 тис.Рік тому
Who should be allowed to receive Communion? | Think Like a Jesuit, Episode 2
How Catholics can overcome the liturgy wars | Think Like a Jesuit, Episode 1
Переглядів 42 тис.Рік тому
How Catholics can overcome the liturgy wars | Think Like a Jesuit, Episode 1
How Father Mike Schmitz balances a popular media ministry with being a college campus priest
Переглядів 8 тис.Рік тому
How Father Mike Schmitz balances a popular media ministry with being a college campus priest

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @albertolucea-jt6dr
    @albertolucea-jt6dr Годину тому

    I have been a devout Roman Catholic since 1961, but I renounced my Roman Catholic faith in 2022 for two chief reasons: one, the Roman Catholic faith is not aligned with the Bible; and two, I was spiritually liberated by the book I read entitled "Altar of Secrets: Sex, Politics, and Money in the Philippine Catholic Church" by Aries C. Rufo. I am now a happily born again Christian . . . much better because its Bible-centered! The Word of God, the Bible, is true food and real drink (John 6:63) not transubstantiation.

  • @albertolucea-jt6dr
    @albertolucea-jt6dr Годину тому

    The Roman Catholic church concept of "relics of saints" is antithetical to the gospel.

  • @Kat-zj5kd
    @Kat-zj5kd 14 годин тому

    now let's rub foreheads

  • @chrisd_man2156
    @chrisd_man2156 18 годин тому

    Satan informing the Pope "He has risen."

  • @user-ei3xv5cc5b
    @user-ei3xv5cc5b 20 годин тому

    The Pope looks really nervous! LOL! I would be too. Trump 2024!

  • @MKK520
    @MKK520 День тому

    Hudson Institute Senior Fellow Michael Doran: "I think the key factor is the American policy because the United States has put a protective shield over Iran . It restrained Israel back in April when there was that exchange of attacks between Iran and Israel." Sky News host James Morrow: "This comes back from the Obama Administration. All the Obama guys are back as retreads in the white house now under Biden! But what is the rationale for saying oh hey Iran they're not so bad? we want to make them legitimate at some point! This seems like insanity!"

  • @user-jv8rm5pw1i
    @user-jv8rm5pw1i 3 дні тому

    ITS NOT TRADITIONAL TO SHT YOUR PANTS IN FRONT OF THE POPE, UNLESS HE'S OPENING THE GATE TO HELL FOR YOU.

  • @ambu6478
    @ambu6478 5 днів тому

    Mr President, you just FARTED before the Pope!! I'm sorry, I didn't realize it was his turn "! Ol' Sleazy Lying Joe doesn't know if he's pitching or catching, but he sure makes a great prezEdent!! NOT!!😂

  • @sophiecrawford2100
    @sophiecrawford2100 9 днів тому

    Humanity desired and freedom and didn't following Gods law. They followed their own desires.its a mortal sin. Synonadality is not about the position,or leader. It's about inner strength. I pray.

  • @laurencefidhburn1845
    @laurencefidhburn1845 10 днів тому

    You know this dude takes it up the butt.

  • @BoulderJR
    @BoulderJR 11 днів тому

    My wife was groomed and raped by a Jesuit priest when she was a 16 year old at an all girls school in Washington DC. Thomas Pyne was a 42 year old priest at The adjacent Gonzaga boys school. Pyne was subsequently identified as a serial sexual abuser of kids. Far too many priests prey on the vulnerable.

  • @user-bw1vg2dc3b
    @user-bw1vg2dc3b 13 днів тому

    Love in Lightness

  • @nicbentulan
    @nicbentulan 15 днів тому

    I feel so disgusted obtaining my master's degree from a Jesuit university. --- Edit to add: Debate me on anything. Go live in Muslim middle east. BTS, Miko Peled , Norman Finkelstein, JVP, Abby Martin, Marc Lamont Hill, Chuck Schumer, Bernie Sanders are all traitors , hypocrites, ingrates, chickens for KFC. 20yo conscripted Jewish soldiers die while hundreds of thousands of Palestinians live from Israel's leaflets. As far as I'm concerned: Jesus = Israel = magnanimous Jew Judas = catholic church, democrats = treasonous Christians (and some treasonous Jews) Romans/Pharisees = Hamas Israel is more than defending itself. Israel's conscripted soldiers die for the enemy's civilians. There is no peace with Jihadists, war criminals, etc.

    • @afriendabroad2083
      @afriendabroad2083 13 днів тому

      Before you pass judgement, how about you google some information first? It's not just Fr Neuhaus who thinks this way there are many Jewish-Arab groups working towards are shared future: Standing Together, A Land for All, Women Wage Peace, Maoz Inon and Aziz Abu Sarah. Also look at Breaking the Silence and B'Tselem.

    • @nicbentulan
      @nicbentulan 13 днів тому

      ​@@afriendabroad2083 Debate me on anything. Go live in Muslim middle east. BTS, Miko Peled , Norman Finkelstein, JVP, Abby Martin, Marc Lamont Hill, Chuck Schumer, Bernie Sanders are all traitors , hypocrites, ingrates, chickens for KFC. 20yo conscripted Jewish soldiers die while hundreds of thousands of Palestinians live from Israel's leaflets. As far as I'm concerned: Jesus = Israel = magnanimous Jew Judas = catholic church, democrats = treasonous Christians (and some treasonous Jews) Romans/Pharisees = Hamas Israel is more than defending itself. Israel's conscripted soldiers die for the enemy's civilians. There is no peace with Jihadists, war criminals, etc.

  • @Steven-tb3qr
    @Steven-tb3qr 16 днів тому

    Thank you Pope Benedict the 16th for your prayers and achievements coming from Marktl, Germany. God bless. God bless quantum entanglement.

  • @brownmouse6121
    @brownmouse6121 19 днів тому

    Because he spoke the truth

  • @ryanscottlogan8459
    @ryanscottlogan8459 21 день тому

    This guy is a heretic and an apostate.Ignore anything this devil says!

  • @user-fw3hc7cr2b
    @user-fw3hc7cr2b 22 дні тому

    The Jesuits are the enforcers for Black Nobility and Vatican They use Khazarian Mafia (International Ashkenazi Jewish Bankers) as their useful tools and money managers “The Jesuit General has been the most powerful man in the world since Pius VII restored the Order or “Company” in 1814. Because of the Order’s suppression by the Pope in 1773, the Jesuits began the Bavarian Illuminati with one of their soldiers, Adam Weishaupt. The Illuminati absorbed the Jewish House of Rothschild creating a colossus of wealth around the world, subject to the Jesuit General." - Eric Jon Phelps: “Vatican Assassins”, 2nd Ed., p. 582

  • @andrewlim9345
    @andrewlim9345 25 днів тому

    Thanks, this interview with Father Nerhaus reminds us of the need for understanding on both sides.

  • @brianbacon5149
    @brianbacon5149 25 днів тому

    +JMJ. The TLM has been celebrated since the Last Supper, not as you state as since the Council of Trent. From the Apostolic Age the Mass was ad orientam. The Consilium implemented a Novus Ordo that radically broke with Tradition and with the Vatican Council. As consequences of the 50 years of the irreverent NO we have seen a switch to a gay culture in the clergy, eradication of Catholic culture, an ugly sexual abuse crisis, and a steady collapse in Mass attendance, marriage, infant baptisms and vocations. The Lord is allowing us to suffer the consequences. Fortunately the demographics and the future of the Church is in the TLM. Our Lord loves that Mass and it is revitalizing the Church with heavenly graces. Over Pentecost 20000 young Catholics attended the TLM at Chartres after making the 72 mile hike from Paris. Ave Maria!!

  • @un.adu.lterated
    @un.adu.lterated 26 днів тому

    Why do American Bishops focus so much on the unborn, while not caring about those already born(immigrants, queers, women, marginalized, homeless, etc.)? Being anti-abortion is NOT really equivalent to being pro-life(from womb to tomb)!

  • @Carla39894
    @Carla39894 29 днів тому

    I don't agree with you because the arabs were the ones that attacked Israel in 1948 and they lost. All the arabs who accepted to live in Israel remained in Israel, the ones who opposed, fled to arab countries. The jews who lived in Judea and Samaria were also kicked out of their land and were absorbed by the Jewish State. The arab countries never absorbed the palwstinians. The palwstinians are the only refugees that remain refugees for all generations. Gazans are actually egyptians and you can see that in their last names. The Palwstinians want to destroy Israel and they don't want a 2 State solution

    • @soulfireonfire6423
      @soulfireonfire6423 29 днів тому

      Yahu never wanted a 2 State! !!! That is why Yahu was all for Hamas !!!

    • @AN-BR24
      @AN-BR24 20 днів тому

      I don’t suppose you would let someone take your land without fighting back, though.

    • @nicbentulan
      @nicbentulan 15 днів тому

      Amen. I feel so disgusted obtaining my master's degree from a Jesuit university.

  • @Carla39894
    @Carla39894 29 днів тому

    Intifada and jihad are in the Quran, long before the State of Israel had its independence

  • @Carla39894
    @Carla39894 29 днів тому

    Not true, Intifada means a holly war against non muslims

  • @james0805
    @james0805 29 днів тому

    You talk about “antisemitism.” I think you Catholics should acknowledge your the church has fomented antisemitism for centuries

  • @rasaltpeso1466
    @rasaltpeso1466 29 днів тому

    Free Palestine

  • @shahesfelazi8549
    @shahesfelazi8549 29 днів тому

    As a muslim having one democratic-just-free state of Israel and Palestine would be beautiful, however there is so much death and hurt, can the palestinian and isrealis be reconciled. If we have two states I don't know if they can live side by side, there will so much to be sacrificed, so much ego to loose and so many people to start to forgiving for so much hurt.

    • @dl1361
      @dl1361 29 днів тому

      It will be very difficult but there are already many who do live side by side

  • @jeanrenault518
    @jeanrenault518 Місяць тому

    J'ai été voir par curiosité (je suis catholique pratiquant) les sites des Evangélistes américains sur la question....Eux ont un discours tout autre, bien plus lucide. Ils ne cherchent pas un pseudo-équilibre entre les "sentiments" juifs et palestiniens. Les Evangélistes regardent l'Islam en face. Et vous, du Vatican, cela vous écorcherait la bouche, de reconnaître dans le 7 octobre une "razzia bénie", dont le modèle est dans le petit livre vert? Les "pieuses" contorsions de notre clergé catholique me soulèvent le coeur.

  • @nicholasdasilva9
    @nicholasdasilva9 Місяць тому

    This Jesuit replaces history with empty platitudes of equal brotherhood while ignoring the fact that Israel is fighting for its very survival.

  • @nicholasdasilva9
    @nicholasdasilva9 Місяць тому

    This Jesuit is way off base. The Palestinian movement is all about Arab nationalism. The Jewish people cannot even prosecute a war without being sided against with a false Both Siderism.

  • @issac6395
    @issac6395 Місяць тому

    Thank god for Protestantism lol

    • @dl1361
      @dl1361 29 днів тому

      Christian Zionists?

    • @dl1361
      @dl1361 29 днів тому

      Christian Zionists?

    • @dl1361
      @dl1361 29 днів тому

      Christian Zionists?

    • @dl1361
      @dl1361 29 днів тому

      I tried respond seven times but it keeps disappearing

    • @nicbentulan
      @nicbentulan 15 днів тому

      Amen. I feel so disgusted obtaining my master's degree from a Jesuit university.

  • @howardgootkin4216
    @howardgootkin4216 Місяць тому

    How do you know what the Palestinians mean when they use the term intifada. You are adopting an innocuous meaning without any factual basis for your claim. The dead give way of your plain bias in favor of the Palestinians is the continued use of the term Holy Land as part of your organization’s name. Holy Land is the name that the Vatican used when it refused to recognize Israel. It is no accident that you continue to use the term of non recognition of Israel Finally you have uncritically adopted the Palestinian narrative of the Naqba which ignores that on May 15, the nascent state of Israel was attacked by Egypt, Jordan, Syria, Iraq and Lebanon, the first three countries invaded Israel proper. Like the Palestinians totally ignore the role that war played in creating the refugee problem. You have nothing to contribute given your blatant bias.

    • @dl1361
      @dl1361 29 днів тому

      The six day war was started by Israel. Easy to look up You got to know what to ask Such as asking google when the Brits started bombing Germany. May of 1940. And the Germans bombed England in September. The official story says they started it. I’m not saying that the Brits were wrong but history is misrepresented

    • @howardgootkin4216
      @howardgootkin4216 29 днів тому

      This is the Nazi like slogan among the anti Israel block: always blame Israel. It is responsible for anything that goes wrong. See for example the wide spread canard circulated among Arabs that the Mossad was responsible for 9/11. Why don’t you Google the Egypt’s blockade of the Straits of Tiran, or Nasser’s massive transfer of Egyptian troops into Sinai. You should also Google the several notes Israel sent to King Hussein to refrain from hostilities. Hussein could not resist the pressure from the Arab Street and commenced military action against Israel

  • @JanaBrooks
    @JanaBrooks Місяць тому

    You mean pretend they aren’t evil? People are already doing that every day. It’s all over social Media and in the news. There are many useful idiots choosing evil. Hamas are monsters. If you don’t know now, you will eventually. Amazing when they recorded their atrocities, people who hate Jews refuse to believe what they themselves have publicly declared. Stop bullshitting yourselves, cause we ain’t stupid. We know and we see.

  • @laserbrain7774
    @laserbrain7774 Місяць тому

    The best christians are in the Middle East and the best jews are in North America.

    • @dl1361
      @dl1361 29 днів тому

      Hmmm. Probably true enough

  • @johnsambo9379
    @johnsambo9379 Місяць тому

    The RCC is the oldest and biggest pedophile organization in the world.

  • @howardgootkin4216
    @howardgootkin4216 Місяць тому

    Your introduction lacks all objectivity or even an attempt at neutrality This is nothing but the traditional anti Israel bias that prevented the Vatican from even recognizing the existence of Israel until 1993. I am highly critical of the current Israeli government and its strategy and you have totally alienated me who is someone you should want as an ally. You are apologists for the Palestinians.

  • @user-pf7tf3rf1u
    @user-pf7tf3rf1u Місяць тому

    Politicians are demonizing the students.

  • @bettybella2417
    @bettybella2417 Місяць тому

    If DEMONS exist within any soul, there will be only HATE & this will bring DIVISION. Only those who understand the characteristics of GOD who is LOVE, and in turn know how to love, these type of people can bring unity & live in UNITY. There has to be a sense of consciousness & mindfulness & respect for life in itself. The reality that we are all CHILDREN OF GOD, The same CREATOR. Otherwise it is only a distant dream or fantasy. SO HELP US GOD.

  • @toddlangis3122
    @toddlangis3122 Місяць тому

    You and your viewers and fans might think you have the moral superiority to manipulative such a clever spin on the Israel-Arab conflict, but all it is is a sanitized false narrative salt and peppered with a lot of half truths. You fail to mention Hamas is the Gaza division of the Muslim Brotherhood - an Islamofascist terrorist entity not only considered by Western nations, but also by Egypt, Jordan, etc. The original Hamas charter is an antisemitic manifesto calling for the death of Jews, first in Israel, then worldwide, and the utter annihilation of the Jewish state. You fail to mention Hamas is a proxy of the Islamic regime of Iran, just as the Palestinian Islamic Jihad, Hezbollah, the Houthis, etc, are. You fail to mention the Arab nationalist - the Mufti of Jerusalem, Mohammad Amin al-Husseini was a Arab Nazi who collaborated with Hitler was also Yasser Arafat’s cousin and mentor. You fail to mention it’s the infusion of neo-Nazi, Islamofascist, Communist, Marxist, Socialist ideologies of hate not only towards Jews, but Western civilization that’s behind the pro-Palestinian narrative on university campuses, fermenting an academic rot of gullible students that’s radicalizing them into an anti-Israel hate cult. You fail to mention how Arab/Muslim colonialism, and Arab supremacy have contributed to the problems in the Middle East. You fail to mention the real Muslim apartheid regimes in the Middle East have committed mass genocide and expulsion of Jews (known as the Silent Exodus), and also Christians (to a lesser extent of course), and the Islamization of biblical regions/countries that were once Christian. With the Iranian regime behind the scene pushing the false narrative of the Israel-Gaza conflict it has proven how effective it is sowing its deceptive seed of division amongst Westerners. It was the Nazis who convinced its youth to commit their atrocities as Christian Europe sinned by sympathizing with ideologies of hate. It’s no different today as history is repeating itself. Is it your moral superiority that deceives you into thinking the same false narratives that blinds you from realizing your sin and the very real threat that’s staring you in the face.

  • @BoborauTierata
    @BoborauTierata Місяць тому

    I love Pope Francis..as true a Servant of Jesus ❤😂

  • @saleemhashmi4131
    @saleemhashmi4131 Місяць тому

    Very well defined the reality of palestine / Israel issue , which rarely analysed without prejudices . thanks to your channel for truthful reportings .

  • @fultoneth9869
    @fultoneth9869 Місяць тому

    Thoughtful conversation. What i have learned: Palestinians can't get recognized while unwilling to recognize the Jews existence. Love is reprocity.

    • @galanis38
      @galanis38 26 днів тому

      The Palestinians recognized the Jewish State, with the understanding that in doing so Israel would cooperate towards the establishment of a Palestinian state alongside Israel. But this never happened, because successive Israeli governments did not wish it to happen...

    • @fultoneth9869
      @fultoneth9869 25 днів тому

      @@galanis38 Both sides blame each other. Lack of trustworthy impartial authority perpetuates human suffering.

  • @fre7717
    @fre7717 Місяць тому

    this discussion ignores the religious undertones. historically, Jordan, Syria, egypt were all christian countries- what you think will happen if muslims come to majority in israel? we already see imams talking about instituting sharia in some english cities, when/if they come to a majority. we already had that situation when muslims controlled those lands- jews and christians were second class citizens. Israel has to have exclusive control of its destiny and military. i do not see a single electorate that includes all Palestinians with Israelis. it ignores the external muslim groups that might influence to make a caliphate in israel/Jerusalem. it is this liberal mentality that causing problems in much of europe. at a minimum, a separate Palestinian state, but that won't happen if they want to take over all of israel. I don't think i am demonizing anyone- i am looking at reality, what has happened in history, what is happening now.

    • @marinamerlini-oberholtzer1553
      @marinamerlini-oberholtzer1553 Місяць тому

      I’m with you but I consider myself a liberal who believes in democracy which needs to be protected by all means. I believe the problem is indoctrination of the young and vulnerable minds who sometimes are too lazy to search for themselves the historical facts. Cancel culture comes to mind as well as the desire of many to jump on the bandwagon. Critical thinking is nowadays way too scarce unfortunately.

    • @fre7717
      @fre7717 Місяць тому

      @@marinamerlini-oberholtzer1553 yeah, i don't necessarily think you imply, but a conservative also believes in democracy. democracy only works when all subscribe to the tenets of rights and freedoms. if sharia introduced in any western segment, rights and freedoms will be undermined. look at the statistics on domestic violence against women in the world- usually highest in islamic countries, where women are treated like property. the pool of ideas already poisoned against israel, where liberal mindset wants to force Israel to take a position that can threaten its very existence. my principled position, only israel should be in control of its security and self determination: this is the only way i see to prevent another Holocaust. i think i am right, looking at how the current protests easily morph from anti Israel government to general anti jewish. and for those that claim to be jewish and hold hands with these protesters - of course, you feel safe, but it is no longer a democracy if you beg to differ and then become a target because you have a different opinion. i am not jewish, but i support jews homeland in their ancestral lands-by definition, that makes me a zionist.

    • @marinamerlini-oberholtzer1553
      @marinamerlini-oberholtzer1553 Місяць тому

      I’ve no objections for what you’re saying and I can assure you you do not have to be a conservative to believe so. There are liberals, the classic liberals that want law and order as well. I’m totally with Israel and its right to exist and defend itself.

    • @dl1361
      @dl1361 29 днів тому

      Yeah the Jews are banned from worship in Saudi Arabia but not in Iran. And in Iran it’s guaranteed death penalty for homosexuals but not in Iran I’m not saying they’re the good guys but there’s a lot more to the story Also look closely at the marriage laws and citizenship laws in Israel along with the divorce rates An unhappy country with supremacists in charge is what I see. I stand with the many anti Zionist Jews. Including Albert Einstein among others

    • @soulfireonfire6423
      @soulfireonfire6423 29 днів тому

      @@fre7717 What liberal mindset is pushing that in Israel? I don’t believe that any Liberals that live in Israel are trying to push for the State Israel to be muslim. If any if them were being that forceful about it , they wouldn’t still get living there so can tell you that! What protest are you talking about they went from Anti Israel to Anti Jewish?

  • @fre7717
    @fre7717 Місяць тому

    9:00, there is also physical harassment of jews- so it is not just flag waving, and slogans- there is physical aggression. i saw videos of Orthodox jew being blocked and pursued as he tried to walk to his destination. i've seen violence against peaceful counter protester.

    • @laserbrain7774
      @laserbrain7774 Місяць тому

      Hysterical.

    • @soulfireonfire6423
      @soulfireonfire6423 29 днів тому

      You did ! Where did you see violence against peaceful Pro Israel protester’s? I saw that video from the so called Christian Expert! Is that the one you are talking about . Where he walks into the university and there were Antiwar /Pro Palestine protesters inside . They had their arms locked and he walked right by them and he never missed a step! The video ends while he is still walking. Never shows him be blocked from anything !! Now if you were to listen to the guy who was doing the video who prepped everyone up before he ever started the video, saying they were blocking him from getting to where he needed to go. Which is propaganda because, he doesn’t need to be giving his opinion or putting a vision in his viewers mind before they see it! That video never showed anyone blocking a student from anything !!! Not blocking him from a door, stairwell, hallway.., nothing !

  • @septcinq1931
    @septcinq1931 Місяць тому

    The Israelis are acting like demons. Hundreds of Palestinian civilian bodies have been found with arms zip-tied, having been tortured and shot. Innocent nurses and doctors are tortured. Palestinians in detention are tortured. Journalists are targeted and murdered so they cannot show what I happening. Is the truth a "polarizing narrative"? I am ashamed of the complicit and comfortable Catholic "celebrities" and clergy. Shame on them. It will be another black mark on the Church.

  • @lapun47
    @lapun47 Місяць тому

    Palestinians have been offered a state at least 5 times since 1948 and always turned it down if a Jewish state is recognized as well. Hamas has pledged to repeat the slaughter of Oct 7th again and again. How have Palestinians been ignored?

    • @dl1361
      @dl1361 29 днів тому

      They were offered an autonomous zone With no control of their borders or water supply I’m not saying they’re the good guys. But when you look at it closer. You can see there’s a reason why Yitzhak Shamir, Folke Bernadotte and Jacob De Haan were murdered The ultra nationalists have won the day The Biltmore conference of 1942 is also revealing

    • @galanis38
      @galanis38 29 днів тому

      The Palestinians have never been offered a viable, sovereign state. For 75 years now.

    • @lapun47
      @lapun47 29 днів тому

      @@galanis38 What is your definition of viable?

    • @soulfireonfire6423
      @soulfireonfire6423 29 днів тому

      Hamas has said that! Not innocent civilians! Anybody who states that all Palestinians are Hamas, support Hamas or should be treated as a terrorist , is just factually wrong. Simply for the mere fact that there is no possible way, anyone has talked to 2.5 million people which half are under the age of 18. So if Hamas said that , then go after Hamas! The “ Hamas is using the as shields” got old along time ago! They can’t have it both ways. They can’t say that they only bomb where they think Hamas is , but yet we have never seen any dead or injured Hamas along with the civilians! So where are they? Then they say they dress like civilians ! So how do you know there Hamas? There the best army but yet they keep blowing food aid trucks, civilians in churches, their own hostages, , journalist, journalist families Enough with the gaslighting !!!

    • @galanis38
      @galanis38 27 днів тому

      @@lapun47 Free movement of citizens throughout its territory unimpeded by an outside power. Right of full control over its land borders, air space and territorial waters. And more. If you look at whatever was offered the Palestinians time and again none of it provided for the establishment of a fully sovereign state much less one that would include a fairly representative proportion of the Palestinian people.

  • @wendyposh7714
    @wendyposh7714 Місяць тому

    Antisemitism that led to the holocaust and ended with Never Again was due to facing the horror because we had images and stories. Oct 7th massacre seems not to be in the consciousness of this discussion. Israeli soldiers are not putting Gaza babies in ovens and committing sexual assaults and sexual mutilations. I heard a Jewish woman say on Oct 7th a young boy 16-year-old boy was castrated and a young Israeli woman had one of her body female body parts cut off while still alive. This was from an eyewitness This is something a nation does not get over in a day.

  • @g_mm53
    @g_mm53 Місяць тому

    Wonderful! Well said. Thank you for this.

  • @gerardmcgorian7070
    @gerardmcgorian7070 Місяць тому

    "Not without the other!"

  • @davidpescod7573
    @davidpescod7573 Місяць тому

    Many thanks, Fr David Neuhaus, for an informative, memorable and very, very moving account of the Israeli-Palestinian situation which you encounter on a daily basis. I was impressed with the importance you placed on understanding your neighbour based on a shared experience, no matter how difficult that may be, rather than be indoctrinated by a media which has little or no interest in peace through justice. Above all you emphasised the utter imperative to see the equality of all; to have the courage to see oneself in the face of the other, and be brave enough to do something rather than nothing

  • @TheWorldsStage
    @TheWorldsStage Місяць тому

    Is it fair to ask people not to demonize others when they are acting like demons?

    • @dl1361
      @dl1361 29 днів тому

      You can demonize a whole people but you’ll dehumanize yourself. The history starts before October seventh and there’s no reason to believe the atrocity propaganda

    • @dl1361
      @dl1361 29 днів тому

      Hopefully this post stays I’ve tried a few times 😂